One Piece Shinsekai - AMV event

[Wiimonkey9]

YouTube - Zoro / Still Loving you

YouTube - Zoro / Still Loving you

[SaA]

i think we have enough entry's now :O

[RoronoaZoro924]

agrees with saa :O

Originally Posted by DeathView

nice video ... but auto fail since sauske/naruto/sakura are in it :/

and no thats his signiture >:O every amv maker should have one (i did when i made amv's)

[SaA]

you to >:O live dammit

[Hitsugaya`]

My input:

If you wanna read, my full opinions are in this spoiler:

Spoiler

Roro:
Footage was good, as was the song, but the quality at times was quite bad. If you can count the number of pixels it’s not a good sign. The maker paid good attention to not only the lyrics, but also the song. (For example I love the part where Zoro does the ‘Crab’-move.) Yet, not often, I did spot some talking and such minorities in between.

SaA:
I must say cheesy pick of the song, but despite that it was quite good. Though there were errors like the makes putting 15% pain instead of 50 (twice). And some German subs here and there. Though he used some nice effects which was good to see. Yet he used the song good (10% luck, 20% skill, …) with the lyrics and showed some lesser known footage. (0:54-0:57, marvellous moment.) But I had to laugh, on 1:34 he says ‘I like bleach, man’ or something like that. It was rofl.

DeathView:
Definitely the best quality. Also a nice choice of the song, with some calmness too. Doesn’t always have to be action. Also the best effect and great to set it in motion with the Ursus Shock. Then showing him in one of his prime, most respectable moments, with a very well adapted ‘flashback’ incorporated in it when the chorus hits. I think this one is slower, but it’s more orientated towards one part, and with the added effects and the good support by the song, I think this exceeds all others in most aspects.

Silver:
First of all, too bad he chose something with the same song as something already submitted… That being said, the effects were great. Though he was too careless with the choice of fragments (subtitles, nearly only the famous ones). And, yea, if you have to look in terms of Zoro tributes, this loses a part because it’s a part for Luffy as well (not that that footage was not great). So that’s too bad for him.

Wiimonkey:
Really liked how the maker used nearly unknown footage in some parts. Too bad about the Spanish subs and mouthing of the words though… Still a really good one, a strange choice for a song, yet I found it very nice, especially in the beginning moments. I’d say the major good thing about this one was just the strange footage and good quality.

If you don't want to read, my ranking is like this:

1. DV
2. Wii
3. SaA
4. Roro
5. Silver

[SaA]

aww i thought i would do better D:

oh well :O

now on to the next one >:O

[RoronoaZoro924]

whats the next theme?

[onepiece99]

not yet :O

[onepiece99]

Ok second theme is up, find a AMV that involves the shichibukai.

[SaA]

does it have to be them all

or can we just pick one