[Vote] Art vs. Art

[ThePspfanatic]

Rules:

• Use the form: +1 V1/V2 - Reason to submit your vote.
• You can't just put a reason such as: ooo i love naruto!!
• Voting should be done both based on appeal and how it relates to the theme.
• Explain what attracted you to choose this particular sig.
• If your reason is not valid your vote doesn't count
• you Can Give C&C in this Thread
• Ex: +1 V1 great composition(How well your piece is put together. Anyone can throw a bunch of stuff onto a canvas and call it good. Not everyone can put it together to form a nice piece.) and colors that blend well together.
• There may only be one vote per IP Address.
• Discussion about getting friend votes in any form or matter will lead to disqualification.

Version 1:


Version 2:

[p2p2]

+1 Version 1 the soft colors n brush works goes well with the emotional expression of the render.

[Hollow]

Win, artist competitions. :O

Okay about V1; I find its quality better and the flower like bg on the right seems to be matching quite well with Aizen. But, looking at it all together I can't help that the blue sky like bg on the other side and the brightness of Aizen's skin reminds me sort of 70s. Love how the neck/chin blends though, by far my favourite thing in the sig.

V2; I find it a better of a theme choice for Aizen with the japanese text on the side and all. I find teh blood spills very nice but a bit over crowded on the bottom. I kinda like it being blurry but it's a bit too much I hink also. Regardless looking at it as a whole it's a very well constructed and appealing image.

So I like them both, but I'll vote +1 V2.

[Mcdanger]

+1 V2 - I like the concept, and the text, including the japanese symbols, and the blood spatter is nice.

v1 is great too but it reminds me of how gay aizen was lol

[Bware the DJ]

+1 version 1
i liked the color scheme and effects are nicer.... the only thing i would say would be to show more of the focal than just the head (it gives floating head syndrome) but that was a small fault in comparison imo

[Jillia]

+1 V2
Reason : i like dark color and the blood pretty well place in the below, the background also pretty well do . . .
[not very good with judge]

[narusasu1]

+1 V1 not a fan of light colors especially with a dark character but it is better art work. Love the brush stroke effect and how it takes on the appearance of a painting. The lighting and shading was done really well and the eye sparkle as well. Colors are too light for my taste and not fond of the brush strokes over his mouth, other then that it is an over all pretty sig.

V2 darker does seem more fitting normally but then Aizen put on a good guy appearance for a long time. I like the text but the splatter and screen effect on this does not blend well to me and appears too faded or dull and the splatter looks well like splatter but no apparent source as you don't see a body and it is not on the character. I do like the background and over all concept but would work more with the splatter brushes gradient maps and shading.

Oh one more thing if I had made a request for Aizen I would of sent back both of them, and I know both of you can do much better then this regardless of who's is who's. Can be a mean critic

[Aclaw]

+1 v2 - the theme goes well with Aizen.

[Aclaw]

delete this post.

[NoIn-LoKi]

V1:
nice lighting and soft colors, good blending and the writing is good
good focal, but is has a bit of floating head syndrome and the effects are a bit overused for my taste

V2:
lighting is right too, nice depth, pretty much leaving the render effectless (which is a nice effect in itself), i think the darker color fit better, going well with the blood spatter


soo…+1 V2