[VOTE] Dual Challenge!!!

[TheAtrox]

Dual Challenge

voting time!

Theme: 2 songs (will be listed below)

Songs:
Spor - Kaori (some hard dnb, kinda underwaterish)
[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g836Lhxp4ZA]YouTube - Spor - Kaori[/ame]

Audioslave - Dandelion (less hard rock/alternative)
[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MG5vMDFFceo]YouTube - Audioslave Dandelion[/ame]


So how do u vote?

Anyone can vote by listening to both songs, comparing how the signatures fit the song and then give their vote to Jeyp or to me by posting: [name] +1
then there should be a explanation of why u voted for either one of us
dont forget that u have to look at both signatures for the songs!

INVALID REASONS:

"cuz its awesome"
"cuz [name] is my friend"
"cuz i didnt like the render its made of"


in the end i will count all valid votes and post the winner

let the voting begin!

Jeyp



The Atrox

[chakra-.-smoker]

i like your sigs

[Chicken993]

They both are AMAZING, but since I must vote for 1 I gotta gmv to Jeyp.
Beautiful flow and they both work so well together. Great lighting and perfect txt. Dandelion one is my favorite of the two.

@Atrox. Your first one looks great! Nice flow and light source! The txt doesn't really fit well though.
Your second looks sweet! Love the lighting although it's a bit difficult to tell whats going on. Glad to see you trying something different with your txt and I love it!

[BlazeCommanderASCE]

Didn't like 1st ones of either of you guys, so the second song decided it.

+1 Jeyp
I'm quite a fan of audioslave, and I think his work fits the song more.

[Lavi]

Atrox, love the first sig, great effects and color but the text is unnecessary and the render seems too ... sharp ? rofl I've forgotten GFX talk, I dont remember if thats the right word xD Text in second sig is much better, nice lighting and depth.

Jeyp both are great, the first is a little simple for my taste, maybe the pen tool could of been used nicely there, but still nice concept and lighting. 2nd sig great compo, depth and colors, overall just a great turn out actually.

tough choice, both were close, I like atroxs first more, Jeyps second more, overall I think I have to give it to jeyp.

[Bware the DJ]

+1 atrox

for me it was really close
both of the second tags are pretty nice.. good use of text of these guys
so it came down to the first and what really sold me was how it fit the theme
atrox accomplished that better imo

[ThePspfanatic]

How do you decide when there's enough votes to declare the winner? Do you have a set date when the voting ends? Or is it a certain vote limit to one person?

[TheAtrox]

oh right ... voting will end in 3 days

[TheAtrox]

we have a winner!


Jeyp wins the dual challenge!

Votes:
3 - Jeyp
1 - TheAtrox


jeez i keep losing challenges


if u are a moderator and reading this then u should close this thread