What version of Boys Over Flower would you prefer?

[jude]

I heard that there is a Chinese version of Hana Yori Dango (Boys Over Flowers)
but i haven't watch it yet, so i prefer the Korean version, i really enjoy watching this comedy drama,plus factor were the good looking cast although it was repeatedly and harshly criticized for its "unrealistic and silly" plot.

So to top it off , for me Boys Over Flower Korean Version is a total unprecedented phenomenon...

No harsh to anybody it's a matter of opinion..

[joeydragonlady]

To be honest, I enjoyed BOF a lot, it was fun to watch.
The best looking cast yet.

But my favorite is Hana Yori Dango coz the cast are
great actors and the script was well written.

I haven't seen the Mainland China version but since I've
read the manga, watched the 3 live action, the anime
and the totally unrelated anime movie and the very
silly live action. I wanna watch it.

[EvilYuli]

Ohh I also watched the anime and that movie(which sucked~).. I read all the manga too ^O^ which was the best of all the HYD creation
About which version.. I think that no matter what I'll probably keep liking the japanese one the most. Good acting, and it didn't get the viewers pissed at anything..

As for the korean version, I did watch like 10 eps I think but then I kinda stopped.. not sure why, maybe I just got tired of it.. Plus, like lots of other ppl, Jan Di's character pissed me off (or maybe it's the actress that I don't like..). Sure I didn't hate Lee Min Ho's acting or the other actor that played JiHoon (okay, maybe just the scen where he kissed his nuna, that got called "dead fish kiss" since they just stood there..), and I do like that they developed the love triangle more. And by the way, what's up with that becoming doctors thing? O_O and whyy doctors? couldn't they make it be something more cool and fitting for JiHoon's character?

The taiwanese version I only watch the 1st season.. It was okay and pretty close to the story line in the manga, but the 2nd season I only watch 1 ep and stopped because I didn't want to kill myself later on because I found i'm stupid for watching it or from the bad story line.... It's like they took all the "Dao Min Si/Doumiyouji memory lose + a 2nd girl who falls in love with him and tries to steal him" into a whole season.

As for the chinese version I also didn't watch it yet.. just the preview which it like a whole ep no matter how I look at it (crazy ppl), and from that it looks like the story line is okay and maybe they added a few things that weren't in the other versions, the actors don't look as good as the other actors, and they dubbed which can make me pop a vain from being pissed.(I hate dubbing the most, no matter which language)

[samurai_annette]

Taiwanese Version = Meteor Shower
or something like that~~
Honestly, I only watched 2 episodes of meteor shower. I didn't like it that much.
But, my favorite is Hana Yori Dango because it was well put out and I loved how the flow was really good. The Korean version was alright, but I didn't like the end

[MaiSana]

I like the Korean version. (mostly because its korean and I know what is in it)
Like 김현중 I love him!! Saranghamnida!!!

[sidb]

i loved the korean version.. the best version of this drama out ther... no doubt..
but i was a little dissapointd with the ending.. i think they could have ended better...
i prefer the ending of the japanese version.. plus they had the movie...
but than again i thought those 5mins music videos for thr korean one wer awsome..

i liked the taiwanese n the chinese version... but they wer not as good as the korean or japanese..

if i really had to pick one.. it would b korean.. but the japanese version isnt far behind..

[Mala_89]

I think that korean verson is beautiful *.*

japanese and taiwanese version aren't bad but (for me) can't be compared with boys over flowers =3

...I haven't watch chinese version yet.....

[shedevil77]

definitely the Japanese version of Boys over flowers .The Korean version was OK but the male lead was not as intense or as obnoxious (believable)as the Japanese version

[pink sugar]

i like the Korean version

[CarpeDiem]

I thought the Korean version was the best....
Ji Hoo was so adorable and I love Kim Hyun Joong.
Apparently, Lee Min Ho (who played Goo Jun Pyo) portrayed the main character the best? I loved the Korean cast (apart from a few of them)

I did like the Japanese version, I loved the girl, she was a good actress, her best friend annoyed me though, I dont know if it was her character, or just her, I didnt seem to mind her character in the other dramas.

Meteor Garden was also good, but definitely not as good as the other two, but in all fairness, its an old drama which apparently said to be the drama that created the drama craze...So it deserves some kudos. Although Barbie Xu annoys me.

I think the Korean version had the most attractive cast (by far) which is probably why its so popular. As for me, Im pretty biased because it starred Kim Hyun Joong. I think everyone should watch all three versions because all three are different in their unique way. ^^