What makes a good manga for you?

[bobbinter]

I am asking you as a manga reader,
what makes a manga a manga?

Is it that it has to be read backwards,
because some manga made outside Japan are read forewards.

Is it maybe that it needs to have a feeling of simplicity.
The drawings shouldnt be too realistic.
Some manga have started to become a bit realistic.

Is it the story?
A hardworking peasant makes it to the top.
This might be the case for alot of JUMP stories,
but manga definitely doesnt stay there for me.

Or could it maybe be that it has to be in black and white,
because some mangas have colour pages at the beginning of a few chapters.

What makes a manga a manga for you?

[Dravenkaze]

deep storyline plot twists and so on

[bobbinter]

deep storyline plottwists make a manga?

So if a forward read comic with colour used deep storyline plottwists,
it would be a manga :0

[pistachio20]

It's a comic from Japan :\

[joeboi112]

yup p20 said it, i would say its that and nothing more, the only thing that makes it manga is thats it from japan, manwha is like chinese or something similar and comics are american, generally there all the same thing although iv never read an american comic

[some1unoe]

Bob I think you can rephrase your question to "What makes a good manga for you" or something, perhaps its more clear that way

[SilverShadow]

Originally Posted by pistachio20

It's a comic from Japan :\

what he sayed

@joe: manhua is chinese, manwha is korean

[joeboi112]

ye i thought i was wrong tbh

[SilverShadow]

Originally Posted by joeboi112

ye i thought i was wrong tbh

rofl dont sweat it i had to look at onemanga to make sure

[joeboi112]

:O cheat