Anime Battle Semi Final 30: Edward (FMA) vs Lelouch (Code Geass)

[Sjcman]

The twilight fans... i mean team edward...I mean the edward elric fans are trying to rally. We must crush them and all hope quickly for His Majesty. All Hail Lelouch and get more ppl to vote

[Vlamidjan]

dear god
this popularity contest is the best ever
both ed and lelouch has taken the lead numerous times
both of them deserve the shot against luffy for the king of AC (even though lelouch deserves it more )

[Sjcman]

Originally Posted by Vlamidjan

dear god
this popularity contest is the best ever
both ed and lelouch has taken the lead numerous times
both of them deserve the shot against luffy for the king of AC (even though lelouch deserves it more )

Personally I hope that whoever wins this wins the next one. It would be a real shame to see luffy win it all.

[Vlamidjan]

Originally Posted by Sjcman

Personally I hope that whoever wins this wins the next one. It would be a real shame to see luffy win it all.

well luffy is a very well made and very popular character that's why he wins
but I already promised that if lelouch goes to the finals I will support him
I like luffy more but a promise is a promise

[Paradice]

Originally Posted by Vlamidjan

the only thing that someone will probably have against lelouch is that he was fighting dirty at times
but i liked this part of his character too
he was a born winner and knew how to get what he wanted
there is nothing wrong about that

You are right that is 75% of why i really do not like him. But it is more of a moralistic issue to be honest. the other 25% is that mind controlling or brainwashing hax's really peeve me. It was that reason alone that i dropped Bleach, and i am not talking about Aizen.

[Paradice]

Originally Posted by Animorphimagi

I was just wonder . . . WHY? Have you even seen ONE season of Code Geass? Cause I don't think you understand how deep of a character he is.

Yes I have watched the entire anime thank you. Partly because I wanted to justify my own dislike of him. Code Geass is a good anime. A very intelligent series but I just morally do not tolerate any of the sides that were fighting. It was like i didn't want Lelouch to have a happy ending. But I didn't want his brother to succeeed. But if it makes more sense to you I also hate Light from Death Note for everything he did. Bad guys can do that as much as they like but for a protaganist, not so much.

[Vlamidjan]

Originally Posted by Paradice

Yes I have watched the entire anime thank you. Partly because I wanted to justify my own dislike of him. Code Geass is a good anime. A very intelligent series but I just morally do not tolerate any of the sides that were fighting. It was like i didn't want Lelouch to have a happy ending. But I didn't want his brother to succeeed. But if it makes more sense to you I also hate Light from Death Note for everything he did. Bad guys can do that as much as they like but for a protaganist, not so much.

you hate light?
then this one is for you

Spoiler

and btw yagami light was the bad guy and the protagonist at the same time
so he can do whatever he likes
if light was still alive then
this

Spoiler

and this

Spoiler

and this

Spoiler

would be possible
how can you hate him?

[Trados]

Originally Posted by Vlamidjan

you hate light?
then this one is for you

Spoiler

and btw yagami light was the bad guy and the protagonist at the same time
so he can do whatever he likes
if light was still alive then
this

Spoiler

and this

Spoiler

and this

Spoiler

would be possible
how can you hate him?

lol good ones XD

and whats wrong with playing dirty? the only place you should not play dirty is when you go 1 vs 1 against equal opponent and if you make agreement with him/her first and from how i remember lelouch had to defeat entire empire by himself ...so as long as he didnt go randomly killing ppl for no reason anything else is ok in my opinion

btw wow i go to sleep and now lelouch is finally winning ....
ALL HAIL LELOUCH!

[Paradice]

Originally Posted by Vlamidjan

you hate light?
then this one is for you

Spoiler

and btw yagami light was the bad guy and the protagonist at the same time
so he can do whatever he likes
if light was still alive then
this

Spoiler

and this

Spoiler

and this

Spoiler

would be possible
how can you hate him?

Those were great Still it can also be refuted that he was the good guy through his actions which is why I used protaganist. Now Lelouch fighting dirty as you would put it, is like i said moralistically against what i believe in and the times he does these dirty strategies he always used his hax power. Which I had no real issue with until he used it on his pacifist sister in the first season. Brainwashing or killing good people to further your own goals does not sit right by me. If he used manipulative means then it may lessen my opinion of him, but still would not like him

[Vlamidjan]

Originally Posted by Paradice

Those were great Still it can also be refuted that he was the good guy through his actions which is why I used protaganist. Now Lelouch fighting dirty as you would put it, is like i said moralistically against what i believe in and the times he does these dirty strategies he always used his hax power. Which I had no real issue with until he used it on his pacifist sister in the first season. Brainwashing or killing good people to further your own goals does not sit right by me. If he used manipulative means then it may lessen my opinion of him, but still would not like him

if you are talking about euphemia it was the only time he used his geass by accident