FullMetal Alchemist Brotherhood Episode 4

these episodes are repeats >.>

I hate this part. This "chimera" episode is the only episode of the first anime that I ever saw and because of it I couldn't stand FMA and wouldn't give it another chance. Because I can't handle what happened, not even as well as Ed does. It just leaves me with the most horrible feeling in my chest. Ugh, it's awful. Awful, awful. Can't stand it... So I skipped through a lot of this, and still feel awful. xD

they are not really repets but retellings. things are a little different. this ep does suck in the fact that that douche bag did that to his own child but it is showing u that the quest for power is paid by a horrible price that should never be paid.

I hate tucker for that... this part of FMA I hate at every version...
Alexander and nina are so cute together<33 but why must Tucker end this like he does?
To make a chimera of his wife and the of hs own daughter... awfull and sad...

dam dam dam of all the episodes to keep i wish they would of left this one out but they counldnt cause its important to the story, but i cant stand this episode y cant he go pick some random person off the street not his own daughter

That was sad T~T

That son of a b****..... That.... Like Spudnick say'd.
Why could he not just go around and do that to random people?`
That way we would call him a maniac or something....
But this...its to much....
My opinion: This episode its a good thing they didnt skip it, as sad as it is, cuz it actoually a very important episode.

I got chills when I watched this episode in the first anime, and with the retelling plus added moments in this one, I wanted to sob. NINA AND ALEXANDER WERE TOO CUUUUUTE!! TT__TT

I wanted that dog so badly before it got transformed..

I don't get why you guys are acting so childish , it's like you're not mature enought to understand whats an anime and whats real life

Yes, but if it were reality would you stand for such an act as that? Like the others this epi really makes your blood boil >:'(

When I first saw this episode, I wanted to shed a tear. Nina was so adorable and her b***h a** "father" destroyed her. Also, although Al and Ed performed a taboo, there situation is totally different from Tucker's.

The only reason I didn't skip this ep is because they actually killed that son-of-a-b****

hate,hate Tucker ,unforgivable to play with human lives ,especially if it is ur daughter ...

wth!!! the chimera wasnt killed like that/there!!she was killed in the alley.. i like the original series more than this but i will still watch this though..

I kinda feel.. sick.. "Lets play" she said.. It's insane... That S of a B!!!

pooooooor niiiiiinnnnnaaaaa :(

The Life Binding Alchemist. For such a beautiful title, it's twistedly ironic.

For the people talking how they don't like this episode, it's meant to be like that. It's meant to be realistic in the fact that it shows that whatever horrible thing happens, the innocent always get dragged in to it, and that not only do they not live to see justice be served, but one last cruel image before they die.

It is to show that 'happy endings' aren't always present. It is there to set the premise that they will have to endure hardships and see 'Hell' along the way.
"You will come upon cases like this in the future. You might even have to dirty your own hands."

WHAAAAT?1) I was really crying at the FMA original episode...its SO SAD!Poor Nina...his own daughter...2)I liked the original FMA version better and 3) WHAT???Tucker is still needed!He didnt die in the original series :S wtf? (Tucker=....AS...OLE........HATE HIM SO MUCH)